That this is the right decision would seem to follow from a certain understanding of the Constitution.
Still, Mike Tuggle offers a different understanding:
The most obvious result of this ruling is that the Federal government can overthrow any State or local law. Worse, the constituency that accepts this view, gun owners, is being coopted into supporting Federal supremacy, and gunowners are on the whole conservative. Therefore, this case will lead a sizable number of activists who would normally support limited government to buy into the notion that the Federal government has no such limits. This can only lead to more Federal usurpation.
Then there’e the subversive doctrine that the Bill of Rights is a comprehensive guarantee of individual rights. This is also a perversion of the original intent of the Constitution. The Bill of Rights was designed to draw a definite boundary of what the Federal government is empowered to do. That’s why the Tenth Amendment was added to make it crystal-clear that the Federal government can legally exercise only those powers delegated to Congress by the sovereign States.
Does an individual have the right to own a gun? Absolutely. It’s a traditional right that goes back to Britain. North Carolina’s Constitution, for example, makes the assertion much more clearly than the mangled Second Amendment. Article I, Section 30 guarantees “the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.”
Our rights do not come from the Federal Constitution. The Bill of Rights was not designed to protect individual rights. To argue otherwise only cripples the struggle to restore the rights that have been taken from us. The alleged passage of the 14th amendment, like the other Reconstruction Acts, was imposed on the people at gunpoint, and the Federal Supreme Court gradually worked what came to be called the Incorporation Doctrine to apply the Bill of Rights to the States. But like any other use of force, it does not make valid law.
It’s ironic that many of the same activists who rightfully dissent at the assertion that the Constitution does not grant the right of secession will accept the notion that the right to bear arms is guaranteed by the Second Amendment. It’s nothing but a snare and a delusion.
Ok, of course he relies upon rights talk, and I will too, as I think it is useful and there is a place for it, though I am still investigating the basis for suchy [subjective active] rights. (Review of Rights Talk at Brothers Judd.)
The question is whether the right to bear arms is a natural "right" or a legal "right." I would hold that if there is a natural right to self-defense, then the right to bear arms is a conclusion drawn from that, and holds the same force as a natural right. It is a natural right, or at the very least a right derived from a natural right (if one wants to makes a distinction between what is self-evident and what is deduced and give different names to "natural" rights accordingly).
So how would Mr. Tuggle respond to Dr. Paul on this point? What should have been done instead with regard to the DC law?
No comments:
Post a Comment