Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Hmm... what's going on over at Taki Mag? First there was the Buchanan-Lukacs fracas. Now there appears to be some sort of fight between John Zmirak and Daniel Larison, two writers I respect. (Edit--The post has been removed.) This in addition to the debate between Richard Spencer and Christopher Roach. Now Taki Mag prides itself as being a place where debate is welcome, in contrast to "leftist" sites which uphold some sort of ideology among all who participate. And Taki Mag does not put forth an unified declaration of principles and stances which represents the views of all of its contributors; rather it is a magazine for 'independent conservatives,' those seeking an alternative form of conservatism to neoconservatism and contemporary movement conservatism. But I think perhaps 'dry' academic arguments, put simply forward as premises and conclusions (or objections) might be a better way to go, then relying upon short essays in which one is tempted to make things personal. We will see if this is just some growing pains for the website, as new writers come on board and all learn to adjust to each other and become aware of each other's positions. But it is a bit disheartening to see controversy among conservatives handled so poorly by some.

I have a post in the works that includes a discussion about 'conservatism'; one of these days I will finish it. Recently Helen Rittelmeyer and Dr. Gottfried have written responses to a definition of conservatism offered by Ross Douthat. Should we abandon that name in favor of something else? Christians should be acting as witnesses to Christ and evangelizing their neighbors. Traditional conservatives and paleoconservatives seek to uphold "Western" culture and tradition, especially its moral [and political] norms. They [should?] also wish to engage in dialogue and working with all of good will (and who acknowledge to some degree the Natural Law?). But who is a better guardian of the Natural Law than the Church? Can a conservatism that is not rooted in Christian vocation and grounded in the Christian Tradition, and lacks the authoritative witness of the Magisterium, be sustained?

More from Mr. Douthat: Conservatism, Defined and Debated, Burke and Conservatism

No comments: