Nature intends us, so to speak, to be social animals concerned with perpetuating ourselves, our genetic material. Genetic perpetuation, for animals such as ourselves, depend on experiencing ourselves as parts of wholes greater than ourselves. But such wholes can only be so big. There's no evolutionary reason to imagine that our empathy could or should expand to include billions of people. So "universal love" and "universal brotherhood" are impossible. All men and women are not, in fact, brothers and sisters.
Is he speaking for himself, or giving an argument? Empathy is not the same as love, nor is it identical to friendship. One should acknowledge that there is a limit to the number of close friends one can have, though this does not mean that we cannot love (an act of the will) all. (Though we are not required to do so equally.) If tribalism merely refers to the tribe as a form of social organization in preference to the modern nation-state, it does not entail hatred of the other, or injustice.
No comments:
Post a Comment