NCReg: A.A.J. DeVille: Did God give man ‘right to bear arms’? By A.A.J. DeVille
Let us grant that "rights" are not immediately given in Tradition. Is it possible that they can be derived by reason, using premises from Tradition or the Natural Law?
Deville refers to Vatican II and John Paul II, as though the documents can be considered exhaustive or authoritative. They can't -- because we are dealing with moral philosophy or moral theology, and not Tradition.
Category error.
No comments:
Post a Comment