Saturday, June 07, 2008

Metro before their time?



The archetypal metrosexual, David Beckham?
Meet the metrosexual - Salon.com
TIME Magazine: TIME 100: David Beckham
David Beckham Is A Proud Metrosexual | Hollyscoop
David Beckham Photos - David Beckham Gallery
Beckham Magazine - Galleries



The metrosexual trend seems to be dying down, though it is questionable that it was popular to begin with, despite the media attention (and hype/advocacy) surrounding it. Then again, I do not have a "night life," so I can't say for sure that the lifestyle is not prominent among club-goers and fine-diners. If there is a specific kind of clothing or label associated with metrosexuals, I haven't really seen it among college and post-college males, though undoubtedly there has been some influence of the trend upon them, even if their clothing remains casual--shirt with jeans and boots or outdoor shoes. But more on that in a bit.

Shows like Queer Eye for the Straight Guy catered to the new-found desire in men to look good and to be perceived as attractive in certain ways. QEFTSG was popular when it first came out--NBC, which owns Bravo, even aired some of its episodes, but I am guessing that there is not much water cooler talk about the show these days.

Now I know two Asian men (one in his late 20s, the other in his early 30s) who were both metrosexual before the trend was noticed. Some obvious behaviors: the use of skin products, certain hair products, especially before going to bed. In addition to "fussing" with their appearance, they were concerned with having an abundant supply of shoes and accessories. One was rather well-off; the other not as much, though he was indulged. In his case, the metrosexual lifestyle should be distinguished from his following the Asian girly look common to many Asian males still (long hair and skinny), since that didn't last too long. Were there similarities in their home situation? It would seem that one parent was more influential than the other--the mother. And in the case of one, maybe the love of shoes could be traced to her. (Though perhaps that would be resorting to two stereotypes, not one. I can't remember if he said he was consciously imitating his mother or not.) Well, enough amateur analysis for today.

Does being a metrosexual have necessary connection with being soft, if by soft we mean someone who is not willing to undertake something laborious or endure difficulties? It seems not, although the two examples I am thinking of could be considered soft. Many metrosexuals are also concerned with their physique and go to a fitness club, etc.; but this is true of many non-metrosexual men as well. As Wendell Berry points out, Americans feel the need to appear physically fit, without earning it through useful physical work. Rather than being fit for the sake of health and fulfilling their vocation, many strive to be so only for the sake of appearance and being attractive to the opposite sex. In such cases, the body being in fine shape has no relationship to the desire to engage in arduous work. One can be in good shape and yet slothful at the same time.

What, then, distinguishes being a "metrosexual" from having a proper concern for appearance and attire? The excessive use of skin products? (As opposed to those who need to alleviate dry skin.) Hair products? Dying's one hair? Merely making an effort to looking good for one's self and for others? Adhering to good grooming standards (as opposed to affecting an unshaven look)? The amount of money spent on care? Going to a hairdresser or hair stylist as opposed to going to a barber? (Among the young males, sporting an earring has gone from being unacceptable to commonplace; the piercing of other areas carries more of a stigma.)

What one wears and does in accordance with good grooming standards seems to be defined in part by convention. So for formal occasions (and for some businesses), one should wear a suit and tie, etc. Can one readily see that the motivation for ignoring these standards, to stand out and be noticed, is wrong? While many are aware of dress codes, there is also a strong social emphasis on non-conformity.

If what I consider being pampered may be adequate and proper care for another man, does this mean that being a metrosexual is "relative"? Or is it relative in the sense that the form of the [male] virtue of temperance with this object, or modesty, has a mean relative to us? Hence, as Aristotle might say, there is no absolute, fixed standard regarding the use of lotion, for example, but the standard is to be found only by comparing with what the phronimos, to the wise and temperate man, would do. And there are other considerations that the phronimos would take into account as well, such as the amount of money being spent. Is money for the care of appearance and body being spent well and wisely?

Mr. Eliot of Jane Austen's Persuasion is supposed to be an example of a vain man. Would he be considered a "metrosexual" by the standards of his day? ("Dandy" doesn't seem appropriate. "Fop"?)

St. Thomas Aquinas does discuss the morality of outward attire in question 169 (of the secunda secundae), whether there is virtue and vice in connection with outward apparel. He holds that there can be a lack of moderation in the use of outward things. This immoderate use happens in two ways:

First, in comparison with the customs of those among whom one lives; wherefore Augustine says (Confess. iii, 8): "Those offenses which are contrary to the customs of men, are to be avoided according to the customs generally prevailing, so that a thing agreed upon and confirmed by custom or law of any city or nation may not be violated at the lawless pleasure of any, whether citizen or foreigner. For any part, which harmonizeth not with its whole, is offensive." Secondly, the lack of moderation in the use of these things may arise from the inordinate attachment of the user, the result being that a man sometimes takes too much pleasure in using them, either in accordance with the custom of those among whom he dwells or contrary to such custom.
It is still possible for someone who follows the customs of his community regarding attire to nonetheless be inordinately attached to their use, resulting in a vice. There are three different ways in which the inordinate attachment to outward things can be excessive:

In point of excess, this inordinate attachment occurs in three ways. First when a man seeks glory from excessive attention to dress; in so far as dress and such like things are a kind of ornament. Hence Gregory says (Hom. xl in Ev.): "There are some who think that attention to finery and costly dress is no sin. Surely, if this were no fault, the word of God would not say so expressly that the rich man who was tortured in hell had been clothed in purple and fine linen. No one, forsooth, seeks costly apparel" (such, namely, as exceeds his estate) "save for vainglory." Secondly, when a man seeks sensuous pleasure from excessive attention to dress, in so far as dress is directed to the body's comfort. Thirdly, when a man is too solicitous [Cf.55, 6] in his attention to outward apparel.

Aquinas the mentions the three virtues opposed to these desires regarding outward attire, humility, contentment, and simplicity. Though Aquinas does not mention them, the use of skin and hair care products, cologne, and so on, can be excessive or inordinate as well.

Still, what if the customs of a society (and the judgments they embody) are in themselves disordered? Can a certain article be said to be too pampering, not only with respect to its material but the form as well? Are some forms and designs of clothing better than others? The problem does not appear to be with the material itself--it is not sinful to use this material as opposed to that (within reason--if the material harms the body, then it would be sinful to use it). As for the form, form serves function, so we must judge both the intended purpose of the clothing, and the form as a means of achieving the purpose.

Can we therefore concede that there is a need for some measure of practicality for the clothing we wear, without going to an extreme? That is to say, clothing must be able to be sturdy and durable, and not just fulfill the purpose of decorating the human body, so as to complement the various tasks man must perform? How can a business suit withstand the physical stress associated with being in law enforcement? On the other hand, should not someone serving the community through a special office avoid the casual (or even 'sloppy') look of contemporary athletic or practical clothing, lest the dignity of that office be harmed?

Is there some higher law to which one can appeal? Or is one always obligated to follow the norms set by society, even if they are counter to what the phronimos deems reasonable? While sumptuary laws may be imposed from above legitimately (or so it seems), can reform ever be brought about from below by individuals acting on their own initiative? Or does this have to occur spontaneously by more than a few men, as it happens with sects seeking to embrace "simplicity" in response to the decadence of their times? Are the members of these sects acting wrongly by opposing the conventions of their society regarding clothing?

Even if the metrosexual trend has been diminished, Peter Pan syndrome still remains, along with the emasculation of men and rampant misandry.

Meet the metrosexual - Salon.com
Metrosexuals Come Out - New York Times
Die Metrosexual Die! by Matt Haber - Nerve.com
How To Know if You're a Metrosexual | How To Do Things.com
AskMen.com - Metrosexual
Amazon.com: The Metrosexual Guide to Style: A Handbook for the ...
The metrosexual guide to style: A Handbook for the Modern Man - Google Books Result
Michael Flocker
The Metro-Sexual Guide to Men’s Fashion
Metrosexual Matrimony - TIME
ABC News: Metrosexual Is out, Macho Is In
Going Metrosexual For A Day - Right Wing News (Conservative News ...

Post begun on May 27.

Pale Cocoon


Pale Cocoon
crunchyroll - Anime - Pale Cocoon
Pale Cocoon | Watch Anime Online

MU

Pale Cocoon - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Pale Cocoon (OAV) - Anime News Network

Animation (Yasuhiro Yoshiura) / Pale Cocoon

Reviews:
Kid Fenris: Pale Cocoon Review
Pale Cocoon, a stunning visual treat « Crystal Tokyo Anime Blog
The End of the World » Pale Cocoon: A glimpse into a forgotten past
Pale Cocoon Review - Anime-Planet
Star Crossed Anime Blog :: Pale Cocoon Review - 69/100 ...

I took a look on Friday night--the ending might be a bit difficult to follow, since the resolution is intercut with scenes from a restored video that the main character had been working on. Does it work as an animated short film? I think so, precisely because there isn't really much depth to the story. But this is also an argument against watching it in the first place. It is well-done and "pretty" in its own way, though.
The Deliberate Agrarian: The Elements of Agricultural Sustainability

Carrie Underwood on American Idol: Idol Gives Back

Idol Gives Back - American Idol

Zimbio





AmericanSuperstarMag


More:
rickey.org
bastardly
monstersandcritics
Idol Gives Back | Just Jared
Idol Gives Back 2008 Photo Gallery
American Idol Gives Back Pictures, Carrie Underwood Photos, Teri ... (2007)
'American Idol' Gives Back. Pretty Much. | A Socialite's Life

Carrie on the 2008 Idol Gives Back Carpet


Carrie Underwood - Interview (American Idol Extra 2008)


Carrie Underwood - Praying For Time - Idol Gives Back 2008

Friday, June 06, 2008

The Confederate Flag

In the news again...

Confederate flag gets HS students barred from graduation
No Graduation for Confederate Flag-Wavers

and

Southern Heritage Group Flies Flag in Face of Furor
Confederate flag display ignores the complexities of our heritage
Why Fly the Confederate Flag?
Huge Confederate flag is raised early along I-75 and I-4
Confederate group plans giant flag in Hillsborough County - St ...

Sons of Confederate Veterans
Sons of Confederate Veterans, Florida Division, Inc.

Wouldn't it be better (i.e. less controversial and yet just as meaningful for those who know what it represents) just to use the Bonnie Blue Flag?


Or is it, or any other flag of the CSA, irredeemably tainted by the CSA and slavery? If there is to be a new South upholding all that was good and repudiating that must be repudiated, one which is composed of blacks and whites and everyone else, maybe a new flag can be created to represent it.

But first enough people need to become interested in relocalization and preserving Southern identity...

Wiki: Flags of the CSA
Welcome to South Carolina SCV Division

Dr. J. Michael Hill, The Demonization of the South
Suzanne Hadley, Flee Sexual Immorality (Sex and the City, That Includes You)
From SciFi.com:

Zetumer To Adapt Dune Anew

Josh Zetumer is in negotiations to write the latest movie incarnation of Dune, Frank Herbert's sprawling SF epic, for Paramount Pictures, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

The award-winning 1965 novel--the first in a series of six books about a futuristic struggle for control of a precious spice called Melange on the desert planet Arrakis--was first adapted by David Lynch into a financially and critically disastrous 1984 film (though Herbert apparently liked it). It also was turned into a more successful SCI FI Channel miniseries in 2000.

Kevin Misher is producing the new version through his Paramount-based Misher Films. Herbert's son, Brian, and Kevin J. Anderson, who have co-written several additional Dune novels, will co-produce. Peter Berg is attached to direct.

Links:
Josh Zetumer in talks for 'Dune'
The Official Dune Website
The Landsraad
The SF Site: An Interview with Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson
Interview | Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson
Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson Author Interview Videos at ...
Video Sandworms of Dune Interview with Herbert and Anderson ...
Hunters of Dune Interview with Herbert and Anderson - AOL Video
Science Fiction Weekly Interview
An Interview with Brian Herbert
An Interview with Brian Herbert
Sci-Fi Storm | Dune News: Brian Herbert Interview
An Interview With Kevin J. Anderson

Lind takes a look at Mexico

On War #261: Not Checking Six

From Chet Richards: Revenge of the Road Warrior--he recommends FROM THE NEW MIDDLE AGES TO A NEW DARK AGE: THE DECLINE OF THE STATE AND U.S. STRATEGY, by Phil William.

Peter Morici, Recession Grips the Jobs Market

Weak Wage Growth and Unemployment
Recession Grips the Jobs Market

By PETER MORICI

From Michael Shedlock: Spin On Jobs, May Jobs: Unemployment Skyrockets to 5.5%

Stephen Lendman, Choice in November - Nader v. Twiddle Dee or Twiddle Dum

Via Carolyn Baker: Choice in November - Nader v. Twiddle Dee or Twiddle Dum, by Stephen Lendman

And NORTH AMERICA'S AMISH COMMUNITY: LEAST LIKELY TO BE DEVASTATED BY COLLAPSE, by Carolyn Baker

Alain de Benoist

A website dedicated to him and his writings, Les Amis d'Alain de Benoist.
wiki
(Nouvelle Droite)

I haven't read anything written by him, but he has been referenced by several writers on "the Right." Is it accurate to say he is opposed to the liberal (dis-)order and some sort of communitarian? I know he's received some criticism from those on 'the Right' for changing his mind about certain things. (Or was it being too accomodating to certain demographic trends?)

Video Alain de Benoist,Propos volés - Alain, de, Benoist ...
Alain de Benoist sur Radio Bandiera Nera 1/5

The De Benoist Archive
Nouvelle Droite - New Right - English articles--
Manifesto of the French New Right in Year 2000
The Philosophical Foundations of the French New Right

Jihad vs. McWorld. An interview with Alain de Benoist | Alberto ...
The Faye-Benoist debate on Multiculturalism
Three Interviews with Alain de Benoist
Alain de Benoist - Stirpes
Alain de Benoist move the left? - OD Board
Alain de Benoist's 'Multiculturalism': A Problem In Defining A New ...
Sandro Magister, The Credo of Paul VI. Who Wrote It, and Why

h/t to Fr. Z

AOL: Twain Talks About Her 'Broken Heart'


(Hollywood Tuna)

Twain Talks About Her 'Broken Heart'
FOXNews.com - Report: Another Woman Caused Shania Twain Split ...

Well, maybe that isn't all there is to it, but this cause would probably seem incredible to any ordinary American guy.

YouTube: Shania Twain - Whose Bed Have Your Boots Been Under

Shania Twain, The Official Web Site - Greatest Hits in Stores Now
shania.net
Shania Twain Co Uk - The UK Shania Site
Shania Twain Centre
Shania Twain City! Home to All Shania Fans
Shania Twain Fan Club | Shop the Shania Twain Official Store
CMT.com : Shania Twain : Photo Galleries
Shania Twain pictures, picture gallery, pics, picture, photos, pic ...
Shania Twain Photos | Videos | News | Absolute Pictures.com
Shania Twain pictures - djmick
TV chef Gordon Ramsay opens new restaurant in West Hollywood Thu Jun 5, 3:11 PM PDT

WEST HOLLYWOOD, Calif. - Gordon Ramsay is in a California state of mind.

Some good news--the winner of Hell's Kitchen will become senior sous-chef, not executive chef as I had thought.

Ramsay will soon welcome another person in the kitchen of the new restaurant: the winner of the fourth season of "Hell's Kitchen." The champion will be offered a job as senior sous-chef at Gordon Ramsay at The London West Hollywood with a $250,000 salary. The season finale is scheduled to air July 8.

Gordon Ramsay at the London, West Hollywood

Zenit interview with Petroc Willey

God's Pedagogy

Catechist Discusses Best Method for Faith Education


By Annamarie Adkins

BIRMINGHAM, England, JUNE 6, 2008 (Zenit.org).- The Church has expectations not only concerning the content of what we teach, but also how we teach it, says the author of book on the work of catechesis.

So says Petroc Willey, who co-authored “The Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Craft of Catechesis” (Ignatius) with Pierre de Cointet and Barbara Morgan. He is also the deputy director of the Maryvale Institute, editor of the catechetical journal “The Sower,” and host of the EWTN series, “Handing on the Faith.”

Willey talks to ZENIT in this interview on why the Church has certain teaching requirements, and how catechesis should reflect the pedagogy of God.

Q: Why do you call catechesis a "craft"?

Willey: We use the term “craft” to describe the work of catechesis in order to evoke the notion of working with loving intelligence, uniting intellect, will and practical skills in a patient work of drawing out the very best and the most beautiful.

The ultimate craftsman in the work of catechesis is, of course, the Holy Spirit, “the interior Master of life according to Christ,” as it says in paragraph 1697 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church; paragraph 721 states that Mary is his “Masterwork.”

In her -- and as her children -- we learn our craft and we, too, can be crafted in the Lord, as it says in the second chapter of Ephesians, verses nine through 10, and paragraph 1091 of the Catechism.

Appreciating catechesis as a craft, therefore, enables us to bear in mind that it is a holistic understanding and application that we are seeking, one that involves the heart, the mind and the hand.

We are also reminded that we develop the skills of this craft always as members of the Church, receiving and participating in the work of grace in our lives. Mary is our model and our mother in this, a “living catechism,” as Pope John Paul II called her.

Q: Your book contends the Catechism reflects the "pedagogy of God." What do you mean, and how does the Catechism accomplish such a feat?

Willey: That the faith has its own specific pedagogy may perhaps be a new idea for us. Paragraph 31 in the “General Directory for Catechesis,” however, calls upon catechists to consider “the demands” and “the originality” of “that pedagogy which is proper to the faith.”

The Church, then, has certain “demands,” or requirements, with regard to pedagogy. She has expectations not only concerning the content of what we teach, but also how we teach it.

This is the case because the faith generates its own pedagogy. Our catechesis is to be inspired by this pedagogy, the pedagogy of God.

We often think of the word “pedagogy” as more or less synonymous with “teaching.” When the Church speaks of the pedagogy of God she means something broader than this. She means the whole of the work of God leading people to share in his life, in and through Christ.

The transmission of dogmas are described in paragraph 1697 of the Catechism as ‘lights along the path of faith,’ as the Holy Spirit, the “interior Master of life,” disciples us in the Church.

How does the Catechism reflect this pedagogy of God? Our book identifies twelve pedagogical principles drawn concretely from the text and structure of the Catechism, principles which have clear and significant implications for our catechesis.

So, for instance, the Catechism invites catechists to bear always in mind the four dimensions of the Christian life, corresponding to the four "pillars" of the Catechism, so as to foster a "holistic" catechesis in which the reality of liturgical and sacramental grace, the converting power of doctrine, the splendor of our life in Christ and our prayerful relationship to the blessed Trinity are all present.

Q: Almost everyone acknowledges that a crisis in catechesis has been one of the main problems in the Church since the Second Vatican Council. Yet apart from select bishops and the Pope, the Catechism is seldom mentioned as an answer to this crisis. Why not?

Willey: The Catechism is, beyond, doubt, an extraordinary gift to assist in the renewal of catechesis.

One reason for its continuing neglect is that people simply have not taken up the keys provided for understanding this gift; they do not realize how it has been written precisely with a view to assisting catechists in handing on the faith.

The Catechism is treated as a reference text, certainly, but not as the aid offered to us in our time for learning and teaching the faith.

Q: There are endless catechetical resources for young people, yet few are based in any way on the Catechism itself. What factors shaped this phenomenon?

Willey: A major factor lies in the use of alternative pedagogies that are neither derived from, nor compatible with, the faith.

Paragraph 149 in the “General Directory for Catechesis” speaks of a “good catechetical method” as a “guarantee of fidelity to content”; a poor method, on the other hand, cannot deliver content faithfully.

These alternative pedagogies, for example, might be based on secular or even Marxist educational theories, or carry with them philosophical presumptions that are incompatible with a realist Catholic philosophy.

Sister Johanna Paruch, from Franciscan University in Steubenville, has recently completed significant doctoral work at Maryvale Institute in England, where I work, on these pedagogies.

Alongside these distorting influences we can see a widespread minimalism in some resources, where very little of the faith is presented, and also what Hans Urs von Balthasar called an “Islamization” of the notion of God, when he is seen in his unity, but no longer clearly as Triune.

There have been significant moves, in the United States in particular, to address this difficulty, especially through the voluntary submission of catechetical resources for an evaluation by the bishops concerning the conformity of these texts with the Catechism.

We are also seeing resources in the United Kingdom such as “Echoes,” published by the Catholic Truth Society, which are formation programs for catechists rooted in both the content and the pedagogy of the Catechism.

Q: In the book you discuss the false dichotomy between the personal and propositional dimensions of revelation. In that same context, you state that the goal of doctrine is love. How can bishops, priests and catechists recapture and present Christ's promise that he is the truth, and the truth is life?

Willey: The Catechism makes it a priority from the outset to exclude any thought of a separation between a propositional and a personal understanding of revelation. Rather than think of propositions as detaching us from God, we need to be aware of their absolute necessity in attaching us to him.

Maryvale Institute is the first Catholic home of the Venerable John Henry Newman, and Newman can help us here because he discovered what he called the “converting” impact of doctrine.

We cannot love God if we know nothing about him. We cannot worship Christ without knowing of his divinity. And on the other hand, we shall never know God fully unless we love him, and we shall never have a clear understanding of Christ’s divinity unless we worship and adore him.

Q: Is it too much to say that the personal encounter with the Lord available to one who studies the Catechism spawns a "catechetical spirituality”?

Willey: This question rightly presumes that a personal encounter with the Lord is available to one who learns and teaches from the Catechism.

The “Compendium of the Catechism” speaks of “the wisdom of its presentation and the depth of its spirituality,” and our book has grown out of an “amicitia catechistica” between Notre Dame de Vie in France, Maryvale Institute and Franciscan University in Steubenville -- three institutions that have firsthand evidence of this spirituality through their courses in theology and catechesis.

Studying, and praying with, the Catechism leads to an increased trust, joy and confidence in being able to speak about the Faith to others, adults and children alike. One is immersed in a text that is precise, gracious, elegant and deeply spiritual.

--- --- ---

On the Net:

“The Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Craft of Catechesis”: www.ignatius.com

Dr. Petroc Willey - Franciscan University Adult Conferences 2008
Petroc Willey - Pipl Profile
Fr Tommy Lane's Work Promoting the Sacred Scriptures in Cloyne Diocese

Zenit: Fr. Cantalamessa's Gospel Commentary for 10th Sunday in Ordinary Time

God Desires Mercy, Not Sacrifice

Gospel Commentary for 10th Sunday in Ordinary Time

By Father Raniero Cantalamessa, OFM Cap

ROME, JUNE 6, 2008 (Zenit.org).- There is something moving about today’s Gospel. Matthew isn’t telling us what Jesus said or did someday for some person, but what Jesus said and did for him personally.

It is an autobiographical passage, the story of the meeting with Christ that changed his life. “As Jesus passed on from there, he saw a man named Matthew sitting at the customs post. He said to him, ‘Follow me.’ And he got up and followed him” (Matthew 9:9).

But this episode is not reported in the other Gospels because of its personal importance for Matthew. The interest in this passage has to do with what happens after the moment of the call. Matthew wants to offer “a banquet at his house” to bid farewell to his coworkers, “publicans and sinners.” The Pharisees’ negative reaction was to be expected. Jesus answers them: “Those who are well do not need a physician, but the sick do. Go and learn the meaning of the words, ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice’” (Matthew 9:12-13).

What does this line that Christ takes up from the prophet Hosea mean? Does it mean that all sacrifice and mortification are useless and that we only need to love to set everything right? From this passage some might conclude that we should reject the whole ascetic attitude of Christianity as a residue of a rigorist or Manichean mentality that today we have left behind.

First of all it is important to note the profound change in perspective in the passage from Hosea to Christ. In Hosea, the words refer to man, to what God wants from man. God wants love and awareness from man, not external sacrifices and animal holocausts.

As spoken by Jesus, these words refer instead to God. The love that is spoken of is not that which God expects from man, but the love God has for man. “I desire mercy, not sacrifice” means: I want to be merciful, not to condemn. Its biblical equivalent is found in Ezekiel: “I do not want the death of the sinner, but that he convert and live.” God does not want to “sacrifice” his creature but to save him.

With this qualification, we better understand the passage in Hosea better too. God does not want sacrifice “at all costs,” as if he took pleasure in seeing us suffer; nor does he want sacrifices that are aimed at placing our rights and merits before him, or that result from a misunderstanding of duty. He wants rather the sacrifice that is required by his love and by the observance of the commandments.

In the “Imitation of Christ” it says “one does not live in love without suffering,” and this is confirmed by daily experience. There is no love without sacrifice. In this sense, Paul invites us to make our whole life “a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God” (Romans 12:1).

Sacrifice and mercy are both good things but they can become bad if misapplied. They are good things if -- as Christ did -- we choose sacrifice for ourselves and mercy for others; they can become bad things if on the contrary we choose mercy for ourselves and sacrifice for others, that is, if we are indulgent with ourselves and rigorous with others, ready to excuse ourselves and quick to judge others. Do we really have nothing to think about, in this regard, in our conduct?

We cannot conclude this comment on the call of Matthew without an affectionate and grateful thought about this evangelist who will accompany us during this liturgical year. Thank you, Matthew also called Levi. How much poorer our knowledge of Christ would be without you!

[Translation by Joseph G. Trabbic]

* * *

Father Raniero Cantalamessa is the Pontifical Household preacher. The readings for this Sunday are Hosea 6:3-6; Romans 4:18-25; Matthew 9:9-13.
Dr. Médaille responds...

Chapter VI will be devoted specifically to Justice, Distributive and Corrective, although every chapter will, in its way, be about this topic. The major sources are, of course, The Nichomachean Ethics and St. Thomas's commentary on the same, as well as the Summa. But it is a case of Philosophy is easy, plumbing is hard. Distributive justice is easy to see and understand philosophically, but its implementation in the real world, its "plumbing" is very hard indeed.

Looking forward to Chapter 6!
AP: Schwarzenegger declares drought in California

Barr and Buchanan on Colbert -- the vids

As promised here:

Bob Barr:


Pat Buchanan:
Fr. Finigan blogs on the multicultural youth Mass at Lourdes.

I like the French school uniforms as well. A decent uniform can elevate rather than dull one's aesthetic sensibility. Haha.

Amanda Shaw







First mentioned her in this post.

official website
MySpace

Rounder Records - Amanda Shaw - Pretty Runs Out - Album Detail
White Oak Productions -> Amanda Shaw
CMT.com : Amanda Shaw : Artist Main



Teen Fiddle Phenom Amanda Shaw Shows NY How It's Done

Voices to hear: Amanda Shaw
MFF: OL - Bonus Audio Interview - Amanda Shaw on GirlTalk - Hurricane on the Bayou
(mp3)

YouTube: AMANDA SHAW @ Louisiana Music Factory 2007

MFF: On Location #6 -The Music of Amanda Shaw


Amanda Shaw - Lovers' Waltz


Amanda Shaw & the Cute Guys


Amanda Shaw - Perridon Two Step


Amanda Shaw: French Quarter Fest 2007, New Orleans

Thursday, June 05, 2008

Dr. Fleming, from the comments on Nationalism, Patriotism, and Internationalism I:
American conservatives have always been, most of them, liberals, if only classical liberals, and liberals see themselves as in the vanguard of human advancement and liberation. Accepting all the twaddle about liberty, equality, and fraternity–as the late Mr. Buckley did for the most part–they could never withstand the assault of the left except when it represented a challenge to property and profits.

What I am suggesting, therefore, is for Americans on the right to jettison all the liberal baggage that has weighed them down, and to subject this ideology to scrutiny and return to a pre-liberal way of looking at society and politics. Although I have utterly failed to make this case, that is what I have been doing for 30 years.

He is finishing a third book "in which the significance of kinship and friendship is elevated about abstract rationality." Wonderful!
Scott Richert, Church and Nation: A Credal Nation, Part 2

I suspect that my failure to anticipate this has something to do with my own experience. Having just turned 40, I still live within a leisurely six-hour drive of every place where all of my direct ancestors, on both sides of my family, have lived for any length of time since coming to this country. If you were to draw a triangle on a map, with the first corner at Rockford, Illinois; the second at Bay City, Michigan; and the third at New Albany, Indiana (or, for convenience’ sake, Louisville, Kentucky), you would encompass the entire area in which lived (starting in 1832) the Richerts and Foremans and Janasiks and Gwizdalas whose various interactions brought about my birth.

To me, this area is home, and I don’t feel out of place among any of the people who live in it. (Except perhaps the Swedes here in Rockford, but as always they are the exception that proves the rule.) On another comment thread, NGPM wrote, “When you are at home, you know you are.” Just so.

From that experience, it still puzzles me that people who do not doubt the existence of a German nation or a Polish nation or an Italian nation find the very possibility of an American nation to be so strange. I’m not suggesting that, in whatever form it may exist, the American nation is on par with those other nations, but simply suggesting that the automatic dismissal of any possibility that there could be an American nation strikes me as both conterintuitive and unhistorical.

Try telling a Northern Italian that he has more in common with a Sicilian than the Dutch, (pre-1848) Germans, Yankees, non-Yankee English, French, and a smattering of Poles who make up the population of Western Michigan have with one another. The latter, while still recognizably distinct as groups in many important ways, also have ties of tradition, history, and genes from 200 years or so of living closely together. Those ties are not “credal” but organic. Perhaps we can’t “define” them, but again, would anyone say that the failure to offer a succinct definition of what it means to be Polish or German proves that there is no Polish or German nation?

While she was working on her Excel Math, CEB told me that her sister told her that she was dumb. Siblings can be so mean to each other.

Ms. N actually asked the class to pray for her today, at 9:30, the time of her surgery. The students told me this, and I told them that they could pray on their own. I didn't want to lead them in prayer, since I wasn't sure all of them were Christian. But I did tell them to either take it seriously, or not do it at all, since some of them were joking around. CEB seemed to be praying earnestly. You can see why she would be one of my favorites.

JM wanted to sit up front to do her math; the boy next to her Jose, made the comment that she was going to stink like the girl who normally occupies the desk, and that she was going to get fat too. I didn't find out until later, after she had lunch. She was about to cry, but wouldn't tell me at first. When the class was lining up, she stayed behind, and wasn't walking with the rest of them.

MGM was absent today--the other students told me that she was not coming to school since she didn't want to be made fun of by someone else at the school. Last week she was passing out invitations to her birthday party--I wonder how many of the students in the class actually went. Her best friend in the class didn't go, which surprised me. I hope she'll come back next week at least.

Another day at school. I had a chance to talk to the blonde third-grade teacher briefly while we were walking to the office. She's looking forward to the end of the school year, and wishes it was the end already. Some of her students saw me walking by and they said she would be absent next week; but they couldn't get their story straight, so I don't know if she's going to be gone for just a day, or for most of the week, but she is supposed to be there for the last day of school. I suppose I'll find out next week, since I'll be at the school until the end.

I saw Anita on Tuesday--she was being somewhat shy. Maria was being a bit mean and telling her to go away, because Anita said she didn't want to be friends with them. Most of the kids do come from poor households; you can tell by their clothes. Even though they are wearing uniforms, many will continue wearing pants with holes in the knees for a while. (I suppose another explanation is that the parents don't care.)

The skill of patching clothes has been lost. Or people just don't have time to do it.

The girls in Mrs. A's class told me at lunch today that their classmate Maria moved back to Mexico. She was just here last week; it must have been rather sudden or unexpected, because even her cousin seemed surprised.
Chapter 1 of Dr. 's book, The Political Economy of Distributism, is now up: Chapter I: What's in a Name?

This is how he explains the failure of the distributivists:

The Failure of the Distributists

Although this book must be a critique of modern economics, it must start with a critique of modern distributists. I say “modern” distributists because distributism itself is nothing more than the rediscovery of an older view of economics. Until the 16th century, there was no real dispute that economics was a colony of ethics, rooted in the political order and dependent on distributive justice. No philosopher or theologian worthy of the name, beginning with Aristotle, was without his economic commentary. He felt it merely part of his natural function to comment on the real affairs of real men, and the economic and political orders were simply part of that commentary. So very nearly the full weight of human opinion, taken as a whole, comes down on the side of the distributists. While distributism adds to modern economics precisely what it lacks to become to a real science—the science of Political Economy—distributists themselves have often been reluctant to put their case in economic terms. They have often argued from moral terms; they have placed their arguments in the necessary connection between free property and free men; they have argued on agrarian terms, on the natural rhythms of life and social order often disrupted by modern capitalism; they have argued from Catholic teaching and the social encyclicals. But on the whole, they have been unwilling or (I’m afraid) unable to enter the economic debate on purely economic terms.


and

Despite these successes in both theory and practice, however, it is too often the case that in any discussion of economics, the distributist is likely to be the least well-versed in the science; he is, too often, the one least able to place his argument in economic terms, and too ready to retreat to moral arguments. This has unfortunate consequences for distributism as a movement. First, we often fail to convince others of the economic soundness of our case. Second, those distributists who have an interest in economics find insufficient sustenance in distributism, and often drift off to Austrianism or Keynesianism or socialism, things which are nearly the opposite of distributism. Finally, we cannot recognize the similarities between our own positions and allied positions like Mutualism and Georgism. And failing to recognize these similarities, we fail to recognize our natural allies. We even fail to recognize, too often, that which is valid and useful in neoclassical and Keynesian theories. All of this gives distributism a parochial cast. We end up marginalizing our own theory, simply because we often have a marginal understanding of the theory.

But if the distributist will only enter the economic lists, he will find weapons to hand and armor enough to stand against any opponent. Our theory is competitive at the intellectual level and thoroughly demonstrated at the practical level; we fill the gaps in the science of political economy that neoclassical economics, and all its variants, cannot. We do not need to stand on the margins, but in the mainstream.

What are characteristics of modern economics?
1. Quantification of human desire and behavior, and economic "laws" expressed through mathematics
2. A lot of hypothetical reasoning -- if/then implications which could possibly be turned into syllogistic form.
3. Descriptive and predictive, rather than being normative, though the predictions yielded by economics can be used in determining public policy/legislation.

So what does it mean to formulate distributism in economic terms? Through quantification? To yield what result/formula? Let's see how the rest of the book carries out this goal.

In the comments section, Dr. also writes:

Property itself, btw, is merely a means to an end; the end is distributive justice, namely that each man (and woman) gets the just fruits of their labor. Property properly understood leads to this result; property abstracted to an absolute becomes the opposite, a substitute for work. But property is not the only way of getting a just result.


This is interesting--I had not come across distributive justice being applied to the fruits of labor as well as to common goods.