QAnon & Living By Lies:
As you regular readers know, this book is about the creeping “soft totalitarianism” in our society, and what Christian dissidents who lived under Soviet bloc communism can tell us about how to recognize it and resist it. In its most simple definition, “totalitarianism” is a word used to describe a state in which all things are politicized. The key difference between authoritarianism and totalitarianism is in the first, the state only seeks a monopoly on political action, whereas in the latter, the state wants to command all aspects of life, and — this is key — to compel not only obedience, but internal assent. As Winston Smith was told, you must learn to love Big Brother.How far does resistance go? In this respect perhaps Herbert McCabe was more daring -- I will get that post published soon.
The word was invented in fascist Italy, but has been applied both to Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, and its vassals. One consistent story that we have heard from anti-communist dissidents is that the entire system was built on lies — that is, on the willingness of people to assent to lies. Vaclav Havel (who was not a Christian) said that the only resistance available to people under communism, where it was impossible to build political opposition, was to seek to “live in truth” — that is, to refuse to participate in lies. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was even more emphatic on this point. The title of my book is taken from his final message to the Soviet people in 1974, on the eve of his expulsion from the country. That essay, “Live Not By Lies,” urged readers to engage in passive resistance to the regime of lies: that is, to refuse to say, or to appear to say, something that they believe is untrue, just to keep the peace.
Totalitarianism isn’t just a left-wing or a right-wing thing, though. Hannah Arendt, in her 1950s study The Origins of Totalitarianism, examined the similarities between both the Nazi and the Communist version of it. I do not believe that we are in serious danger in the United States of a right-wing version of soft totalitarianism, for various reasons. The danger from the right is authoritarianism — which is a bad thing, but a different thing. As you’ll see in the book, the main reasons I believe the real threat comes from the left has to do with the fact that the values of the progressive left are dominant in Americans under 40 (meaning that the future is on the left); the fact that the institutional elites are heavily dominated by cultural progressives; that progressivism is illiberal, and will not tolerate dissent; and that our society has become one in which the masses want nothing more than comfort and happiness. We are preparing for a soft Huxleyan totalitarianism, not a hard Orwellian one.
This is the uselessness of the old "left/right" division; and an "authoritarian" regime of the right isn't conserving anything except its own power, because the state is an insufficient bearer of any sort of communitarian tradition rooted in the Natural Law. Unless he wants to discuss specific historical regimes, Franco's Spain, for example. There is only statism, and various kinds of statism, or statism with different laws and overarching goals.
This is not the first time that Dreher has quoted Arendt; other "conservatives" have done so, iirc. She may have gotten some of the diagnosis correct, but she is rather overrated, and held up only because she was a woman (and a member of a certain minority).
Hannah Arendt And The Jewish Question by Richard J. Bernstein
Hannah Arendt: Jew and Cosmopolitan by Natan Sznaider
Is Hannah Arendt a Jewish Thinker?
Is the application of Arendt thinking about a rootless, people without community, whose identity, culture, and history are under attack? Dreher is right to point out the risks for both red Americans and blue Americans to fall under the spell of totalitarianism.
Related:
No comments:
Post a Comment