Showing posts with label John McCloskey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John McCloskey. Show all posts

Sunday, May 08, 2016

The Catholic Thing: On the Importance of Friendship by Fr. C. John McCloskey III

A bit of pedestalizing here? "(Women, on the whole, seem to do much better in befriending one another.)"

And then there's this:
As one author once wrote, “the average American male has one good friend, and that is his wife” (or, more likely in our era of declines in marriage, his ‘significant other”). Anyone who has spent an extended period in a country with a Catholic cultural background (whether or not actual religious practice has plummeted) has probably noticed how profoundly American men have been affected by our overwhelmingly Protestant culture, with its emphasis on individualism. There is a very powerful image of the strong, isolated male figure in American culture: the autonomous adventurer who rides off into the sunset; the “strong, silent type” who hides his private feelings behind a crusty exterior; the man who is ultimately answerable only to his own conscience.

Is this ideal more true of one group of settlers from the British isles than the others? (The Scots-Irish, perhaps?) Or is it an erroneous projection of an ideal perpetuated by 20th century American pop culture onto Protestantism?

Tuesday, February 16, 2016

An Unexpected Recommendation

I didn't know of Fr. M cCloskey's personal connection to Joe Sobran.

The Importance of Sobran by Fr. C. John McCloskey III

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

But Where are the Statistics?

And do they give a complete picture of why marriages between American Catholics "fail"?

Pornography: Our Greatest Ongoing Spiritual Threat by Fr. C. John McCloskey

"Although pornography is overwhelmingly marketed to and viewed by men, a substantial number of women also sample it out of curiosity and generally are disgusted by it (although a small number fall into the trap of using it themselves)."

As a commentator points out, why is Father McCloskey ignoring pornography geared towards women? This is socon white-knighting at its worse and does nothing to address the actual problem of pornogaphy use for members of both sexes. At least Matt Fradd deals with the problems of pornography for members of both sexes. But is porn use the big problem or more of an effect of deeper problems that remain unaddressed by Roman Catholics?

Tuesday, September 22, 2015

EWTN Coverage of Pope Francis's Visit to the US

Here - complete schedule

Ignoring all of it, not even doing any liturgy monitoring.

A Priest’s Hopes for the Pope’s Visit by Fr. C. John McCloskey

Eight-hundred and fifty ordinary Americans from across the United States sent small items of silver for the making of a...

Posted by Vatican Radio - English Section on Tuesday, September 22, 2015

Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York joins “CBS This Morning” to discuss the significance of the pope’s historic U.S. visit.

Posted by Vatican Radio - English Section on Tuesday, September 22, 2015

Thursday, August 20, 2015

Wednesday, June 10, 2015

Fr. Schall on Marriage

On the Logic of Morals by James V. Schall, S.J.

Related:
Friendship and Evangelization by Fr. C. John McCloskey

I think his genealogy/intellectual history is off, but his prescriptions sound correct, though he does not address feminism. (And is unlikely to do so in a way that goes beyond Catholic feminism.)

Wednesday, May 13, 2015

But There is No Common Good

The problematic premise upon which this piece is based: Some Catholic Preliminaries to the Presidential Campaign by Fr. C. John McCloskey.

There is no common good because we do not live in a political community but in a unitary nation-state which replaced the federation of states that existed before Abraham Lincoln, a nation-state in which physical mobility, industrial capitalism, the growth of megapoleis, the creation of neo-Yankee "proposition nation" identity, and other causes have wrecked many local communities in which a true common good was instantiated.

If Opus Dei (of which Fr. McCloskey is a prominent American spokesman) cannot get its politics right, its take on lay spirituality will remain lacking. (And the advice of priests on American politics will be erroneous.)

Video Summary of Ordination of 32 Priests (Future Priests Talk About Their Priesthood)